Who Should retire: Brett Favre. Good old Brett wants to come back for season 17. One can only think to herself… WHY?! His team is half his age, and if he wants a realistic shot at another Super Bowl with Green Bay, he’s going to have to stick around for at least another four years. Favre is so far past his prime, his prime is detailed in history books. If anything, he’s severely hindering the growth and progress of that young team. There, I said it. Someone had to.
Who Shouldn’t retire: Tiki Barber. Okay, I do realize that an NFL running back takes an epic beating week after week. I also understand that he feels he has accomplished all that he can in the NFL. I’m just not ready to let him go. *tear* The Giants do have a realistic shot at the Big Game, so long as they can stay relatively healthy, of course.